The Boundless Bible

QUICK Qs: Would You Choose Faith Made of Brain or Heart?

The Boundless Bible Season 1 Episode 55

David, Jason, and Javi debate whether they would choose to be "all brain" or "all heart" in their spiritual journeys, revealing surprising personal preferences and examining what sustains faith through life's challenges.

• David surprisingly admits he wishes for an "all heart" faith where he could accept scripture without questioning
• Despite his cerebral approach, David acknowledges feelings of God's presence matter more than theological details
• Jason chooses "all brain," explaining how apologetics provides a safeguard if emotional connection to faith wavers
• Jason's fear of losing faith during potential tragedy led him to build an intellectual foundation through apologetics
• Javi believes the heart is the "right answer," noting how intellectual curiosity led him to faith but heart kept him there
• The hosts share a powerful seminary lesson: "You're never going to teach somebody how to love God, but you can love them in such a way that they end up loving God"


Send us a text

Support the show

Have a topic, verse, or story you'd like us to cover?

  • Tell us on the socials at @theboundlessbible:
    Facebook / Instagram / TikTok
  • Join the new Facebook Group: The Boundless Bible Discussion Group

If you enjoyed this episode, hit subscribe and leave a review—it helps us reach more people like you.

David:

Welcome to the Boundless Bible. My name is David Shapiro, hey, I'm Javi Marquez and I'm Jason Holloway.

Jason:

Quick questions with David and we're back with quick questions.

David:

All right for this week in your journey, in your walk with Christ, would you rather be all brains or all heart.

Jason:

This is such an easy question for me. I want to be all heart all the time and I would love to have that kind of faith where I never had to ask a single question. I just accepted it at face value that I could read the Bible and read it word for word, what's literally on the page, exactly as it is on the page, and not question how it influences any other system or thought. I would. Oh, that would be such a dream for me. So that's mine Plus, and I should add too I mean plus.

Jason:

Look, as I go through my walk and my walk is so cerebral I continue to realize that, no matter how cerebral I get or how much I start thinking about things, the thing that actually matters at the end of the day is the feeling. And even when I'm struggling with some concept or theological discussion point, if I just stop and go, what does it feel like? And do I feel the presence of God? And do I feel the sense of peace that I'm get, that I, that I, you know? Do I feel a sense of peace when I think of him? And do I feel the sense of peace that I'm getting that I, that I, you know, do I feel a sense of peace when I think of him? And the answer is yes, and that's so much bigger than like. Do I understand how many angels are on the head of a pin? You know, that's good.

David:

For me it's the whole reason why I got into apologetics. So for me it's going to be all brains. And the reason is that when I started following Christ I heard a lot of people who were saying, hey, I used to go to church when I was younger, I don't go anymore. And it reminded me a lot of my martial arts experience, where a lot of people said when I was a kid I took martial arts and then I stopped and my fear was if something ever happened to me emotionally, somebody passed away, something tragic happened and I lost the feeling. What would happen then? I didn't want my life without Christ. So I began my studies into apologetics so that my brain can take over if that ever happened. And I think because of that I just, you know, I fell into an area where I really love the research. I love the theory, I love the logic, I love the truth of the theory, I love the logic, I love the truth of it. So I think mine would have to be all brain.

Javi:

Makes sense, makes sense, I love.

Jason:

Javi, where are you at?

Javi:

answer. I feel like the easy answer and the right answer is your heart. Um just saying, but um.

Jason:

I did the right answer.

Javi:

I'm saying, I'm saying that only because you, to me, the question is saying you won't have the other, so I would have the heart. You know, and I think that's something as I look at the faith God really wants us to really check all the time is your posture of your heart, um, and pretty much, follow me, uh, seek me, do the things that I asked you to do with your heart, not with intelligence and second guessing, as we saw the apostles do a lot of times. Um, not to say that if you were to have brains, you were second guess. But, um, I'm kind of in the same boat, david.

Javi:

I think you're obviously more intellectual, you, you went and got your doctrine. Congrats to you, brother. But for me, I think I'm the same way, like, meaning, like, as I came into the faith, I was what continued to lead me further into the faith was the intellectual wanted to know more, wanted to actually see how, maybe true, this grounded in something more than just stories. So that's what led me into the faith knowing, wanting to know more about God, jesus and just everything that's around the faith. But the heart is what kept me, uh, going for this long, and I think it was something that would continue to keep me um, just a love for faith and for God and for other people Love it.

Jason:

Yeah, and I almost feel the, I almost feel this necessity to say something that I heard. One one of the pastors at church said something that they were in seminary and like. One day the professor closed the book and said I just want you to realize you're never going to teach somebody how to love God, but you can love them in such a way that they end up loving God. And that one stuck with me for a while. So, thanks, pastor G. It's such an important and and, uh, incredible thing to remember, which is that that's where God lives. He lives in the love, he lives in the care, he lives in the expression of love that other people show, the outward expression of people that they show because of his love and because of what he offers them. So that one stuck with me. So, all right, guys, thanks for another. Quick questions Always, always fun, and we look forward to talking to you again next week, later. Bye, bye.

People on this episode

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

The BEMA Podcast Artwork

The BEMA Podcast

BEMA Discipleship
Ask NT Wright Anything Artwork

Ask NT Wright Anything

Premier Unbelievable
BibleProject Artwork

BibleProject

BibleProject Podcast